by Ward Dean, M.D.,
and Steven Wm. Fowkes
Dehydroepiandrosterone (pronounced dee-hi-dro-epp-ee-ann-dro-stehr-own),
or DHEA as it is more often called, is a steroid hormone produced
in the adrenal gland. It is the most abundant steroid in the
bloodstream and is present at even higher levels in brain
tissue. DHEA levels are known to fall precipitously with age,
falling 90% from age 20 to age 90. DHEA is known to be a precursor
to the numerous steroid sex
hormones (including estrogen and testosterone) which serve
well-known refunctions, but the specific biological role of
DHEA itself is not so well understood. It is difficult for
searchers to separate the effects of DHEA from those of the
primary sex steroids into which it is metabolized. The apparent
lack of any direct hormone action for DHEA has prompted the
suggestion that it may serve the role of a “buffering
hormone” which would alter the state-dependency
of other steroid hormones. Although the specific mechanisms
of action for DHEA are only partially understood, supplemental
DHEA has been shown to have anti-aging,
anti-obesity and anti-cancer influences. In addition, it is
known to stabilize nerve-cell growth and is being tested in
Alzheimer’s patients.
DHEA and Cancer
Early reports from England [Bulbrook, 1962, 1971] suggested
that DHEA was abnormally low in women who developed breast
cancer, even as much as nine years prior to the onset or diagnosis
of the disease. Of the 5000 women followed in the study, 27
developed cancer. Most of the 27 had abnormally low levels
of DHEA. If low DHEA levels contributed to breast cancer,
might the opposite be true? Many years later, Dr. Arthur Schwartz
of Temple University found that supplemental DHEA significantly
protected cell cultures from the toxicity of carcinogens.
Cell cultures usually respond to powerful carcinogens with
mutations (changes in DNA), transformations (changes in cell
appearance), and a high rate of cell death. But when Schwartz
added DHEA along with the carcinogen, all three of these effects
were significantly diminished.
Subsequent studies [Schwartz, 1979] identified powerful protective
effects of supplemented DHEA for breast-cancer-prone mice.
The results of the experiment was clear after 8 months. The
control animals were “getting cancer left and right”
while the DHEA animals had no tumors. In two later studies
with different strains of mice, Schwartz found 75% and 100%
reductions in tumor incidence at 8 months of age and 50% and
75% reductions at 15 months of age [Schwartz, 1981; 1984].
DHEA has demonstrated protective effects for cancers of the
skin, lungs, bowel, breast and liver. According to William
Regelson, “Whenever [DHEA] has been tested in a model
of carcinogenesis and tumor induction, DHEA has preventative
effects.” Although DHEA is now beginning to be tested
in human cancer, it is still to early to know whether the
successes achieved in animals will be realized in humans.
The Anti-Obesity Factor
At about the same time that Schwartz was investigating the
anti-cancer properties of DHEA, Dr. Terrence T. Yen was studying
the effect of DHEA on genetically obese mice. Although the
DHEA-treated mice ate normally, they remained thin —
and they lived longer than control mice. This “leanness”
effect was also conspicuously noted by Dr. Schwartz. In another
experiment, Dr. M. P. Cleary found that even middle-aged obese
rats lost weight when fed DHEA-supplemented food. Diabetes,
a typical complication of obesity, was also dramatically decreased.
DHEA and Glucose Metabolism
Investigators have shown that DHEA inhibits glucose-6-phosphate
dehydrogenase (G6PDH), an enzyme that breaks down glucose.
There are two glucose-metabolizing pathways in the body, the
catabolic, energy-yielding pathway and the anabolic, biosynthetic
pathway. G6PDH happens to be the first enzyme in the biosynthetic
pathway, the one which results in the synthesis of fatty acids
and ribose (the sugar used in making deoxyribonucleic acid,
or DNA). In simple language, G6PDH turns glucose into fat.
DHEA’s inhibition of G6PDH may redirect glucose from
anabolic fat-production into catabolic energy metabolism,
thus creating a leaner metabolism. This function of DHEA is
well reviewed by Arthur Schwartz and colleagues in their chapter
on “The Biological Significance of Dehydroepiandrosterone”
in The Biologic Role of Dehydroepiandrosterone. They assert
that DHEA-mediated reductions in ribose-5-phosphate activity
may be centrally responsible for the anti-tumor promoting,
anti-tumor initiating, and possibly the anti-atherogenic properties
of DHEA. They also note that DHEA 1) produces hepatomegaly
(liver enlargement), 2) stimulates liver catalase activity
(a protective antioxidant enzyme), and 3) causes proliferation
of peroxisomes (cellular organelles which specialize in oxidative
processing and the decomposition of hydrogen peroxide). The
absence of such influences with synthetic analogs of DHEA
(like 16-alpha-fluoro-5-androsten-17-one) prompts Schwartz
and colleagues to recommend that such analogs be considered
for clinical applications in humans. Toxicity factors still
need to be assessed.
DHEA and Appetite
In different experiments, DHEA supplementation has resulted
in increased, decreased and unchanged food consumption. Dr.
Schwartz found that it is the level of dietary fat influences
food consumption. DHEA-treated rats on a high-fat diet ate
less food than control rats while those on a low-fat diet
ate more.
Since DHEA inhibits G6PDH activity and suppresses the body’s
ability to synthesize fat from carbohydrate, dietary sources
of fat become more important. This can affect changes in appetite.
But despite possible increases in food intake, DHEA-treated
animals consistently weighed less than control animals. In
other words, increases in appetite, when indulged, did not
negate the anti-obesity property of DHEA.
DHEA and Aging
The body’s production of DHEA drops from about 30 mg
at age 20 to less than 6 mg per day at age 80. According to
Dr. William Regelson of the Medical College of Virginia, DHEA
is “one of the best biochemical bio-markers for chronologic
age.” In some people, DHEA levels decline 95% during
their lifetime — the largest decline of an important
biochemical yet documented.
In animal studies, DHEA extends rodent lifespans up to 50%.
The animals not only lived longer, they looked younger. The
graying, course-haired controls could easily be distinguished
from the sleek, black-haired, DHEA-treated animals.
DHEA levels are directly related to mortality (the probability
of dying) in humans. In a 12-year study of over 240 men aged
50 to 79 years, researchers found that DHEA levels were inversely
correlated with mortality, both from heart disease and from
all causes. This finding suggests that DHEA level measurements
can become a standard diagnostic predictor of disease, mortality
and lifespan. Furthermore, if animal results hold true, supplemental
DHEA may prevent disease, reduce mortality, and extend lifespan
in humans.
Enhancing Brain Function
DHEA may also be intimately involved in protecting brain neurons
from senility-associated degenerative conditions, like Alzheimer’s
disease. Not only do neuronal degenerative conditions occur
most frequently when DHEA levels are lowest, but brain tissue
contains many times more DHEA than is found in the bloodstream.
One of the scientists at the forefront of this field of research
is Dr. Eugene Roberts who found that very low concentrations
of DHEA were found to “increase the number of neurons,
their ability to establish contacts, and their differentiation”
in cell cultures. He also found that DHEA also enhanced long-term
memory in mice undergoing avoidance training. It may play
a similar role in human brain function.
Drs. Roberts and Fitten report initial research on “Serum
steroid levels in two old men with Alzheimer’s disease
before, during and after oral administration of DHEA”
in the book The Biologic Role of Dehydroepiandrosterone. Roberts’
and Fitten’s data are the best we’ve seen regarding
acute and chronic changes in numerous hormone levels following
various oral doses of DHEA (see adjacent graphs). Because
of the short peak duration of DHEA (heavier line in illustration),
they recommend that future studies or therapeutic trials use
time-release capsules or transdermal patches to provide more
uniform delivery of DHEA.
Levels of pregnenolone and 17-alpha-pregnenolone, the direct
precursors to DHEA, were too low to be measured in the two
patients illustrated, but Roberts and Fitten present data
from three other Alzheimer’s patients. Their data indicate
that in all three patients, “control values for pregnenolone
and 17-alpha-pregnenolone not only were below the means for
the population controls, they were lower than the lowest values.”
In other words, the highest of the Alzheimer’s patients
was lower than the lowest of the population controls. When
they were administered 400 mg of DHEA, all three experienced
decreased levels of 17-alpha-pregnenolone. Pregnenolone levels
increased in two patients and fell in the third. In the two
patients experiencing increased pregnenolone and decreased
17-alpha-pregnenolone in response to DHEA, levels of 17-alpha-pregnenolone
rebounded strongly at 24 hours. Roberts and Fitten suggest
that “a prolonged inhibition of 17-alpha hydroxylation
occurred as a result of continued DHEA intake.”
DHEA and Immune Function
DHEA is known to enhance general immune response. Oral and
subcutaneous DHEA has been observed to protect rodents against
the lethality of RNA and DNA viruses, and lethal bacterial
infections. Drs. Loria, Regelson and Padgett report in The
Biologic Role of Dehydroepiandrosterone (DHEA) that a single
subcutaneous dose of DHEA is considerably more effective in
protecting against infection than oral dosing. Intraperitoneal
[within the abdominal cavity] injections were completely ineffective.
Dr. Loria and colleagues noted that subcutaneous dosing did
not result in the typical weight loss observed with oral DHEA.
Presumably it works by a different mechanism. DHEA has been
reported to counteract the thymic involution [shrinking of
the thymus gland] and immuno-suppression caused by corticosteroids.
But the special role of skin tissues in the immune facilitating
properties of DHEA suggest a different mechanism is involved.
Cutaneous immune cells, such as Langerhans cells and keratinocytes,
are believed to play a role in “immune surveillance”
and “antigen presentation.” These cells may be
a site of DHEA’s action. Subcutaneous injection of DHEA
results in the “formation of a local deposit leading
to a relatively prolonged exposure to the lymphoid system.”
DHEA skin patches might provide a similar exposure.
The delay in protective effect of subcutaneous DHEA has prompted
Loria and colleagues to postulate that a DHEA metabolite is
involved in cutaneous immune enhancement. In a recent paper
[Loria and Padgett, 1993], they advance androstenediol [5-androsten-3-beta-17-beta-diol]
as the active metabolite, the production of which is predominantly
localized in the skin and brain. They found that androstenediol
was significantly more effective than DHEA (10,000 times more
with coxsackievirus B4!).
Neither DHEA nor androstenediol have any direct (in vitro)
antiviral activity. The amount of viral load in heart, spleen,
pancreas, liver and blood tissues was unaffected by either
DHEA or androstenediol administration. The effect of these
steroids appears to be strictly mediated through stimulation
of lymphocytes, lymphoid organs, and immune-modulating cytokines
[immune hormones].
DHEA: The Buffering Steroid?
DHEA may be unique among hormones for it’s lack of specificity
forhormone receptor sites. Just as vitamin E has never been
shown to have a specific metabolic role (it is only proven
essential as a general antioxidant), DHEA may serve an equally
general purpose. “DHEA is the first example of a buffer
action for hormones that I know of,” states William
Regelson. “It is a broad-acting hormone that only demonstrates
itself under a specific set of circumstances. In that way,
it is like a buffer against sudden changes in acidity or alkalinity.
That is why when you get older, you’re much more vulnerable
to the effects of stress. As DHEA declines with age, you are
losing the buffer against the stress-related hormones. It
is the buffer action that [helps prevent] us from aging.”
The decrease of DHEA with age may result in gradual decline
of a system for suppressing enzyme systems responsible for
creating the building blocks of new cells, like lipids, nucleic
acids (RNA and DNA) and sex steroids. The resulting rise in
enzymatic activity in advanced age may be responsible for
the proliferative events (cancer) and degenerative disease
that become more frequent in advanced age. In this respect,
DHEA might be best considered to be an anti-hormone, which
might “de-excite” steroid-sensitive receptors
that would otherwise lead to enhanced metabolic activity.
Dosage
Exact dosages for humans have not been clearly determined.
Daily dosages vary from 5 to 10 mg to as much as 2000 mg,
with 5, 10, 25 and 250 mg being the range for typical tablet
and capsule sizes. DHEA is usually split into 2-4 daily doses,
especially at the higher dosage levels.
We recommend that dosage be adjusted to bring blood DHEA and
DHEA-S measurements towards young-adult levels. These blood
tests can be ordered by your physician (don’t forget
to get your first test before you start taking DHEA).
Conclusion
Because of its generally universal function in human metabolism,
DHEA is being associated with numerous human maladies. For
example, DHEA has recently been found to have a highly statistically
significant correlation with vertebral bone density in postmenopausal
women suggesting that DHEA (and other weak androgens) may
protect against osteoporosis. This, and its low toxicity,
may tend to give DHEA the same panacea stigma that the antioxidants
vitamin E and C suffer.
Regulatory Difficulties
In Europe, DHEA is already available as a drug in 5 and 10
mg doses (although it has been hard to obtain). It is used
primarily for the treatment of menopause. In the United States,
DHEA must first be approved as a drug by the FDA before it
can be marketed for medical purposes. Unfortunately, this
is an adversarial process (the drug companies advocating for
the drug and the FDA demanding proof of efficacy and safety)
which takes up to 100 million dollars and a decade to accomplish.
Without a patent to restrict competition, prices cannot be
raised high enough to recover the investment in the approval
process. DHEA is an unpatentable substance.
|